Comparison of the field trapping efficacy of different trapping products on two species of fruit flies

doi:10.16178/j.issn.0528-9017.20250410

Abstract

Abstract:

Fruit flies represent an important group of invasive and quarantine pests that are frequently disseminated through the transportation of fresh fruits and vegetables，resulting in substantial damage to agricultural production in many invaded regions. Consequently，the development and implementation of effective monitoring programs and environmentally sustainable control strategies are imperative. The study evaluated the field-trapping efficacy of six trapping products on Zeugdacus tau and Zeugdacus scutellata，in order to screen out optimal trapping product for green control of fruit flies in Zhejiang Province. The results indicated that sexual lure products exhibit significantly greater trapping efficacy for fruit flies compared with color or food lure products. The ranking of trapping efficacy of four sexual lure products was as follows：Sex Pheromone Sticky Card Trap>Lieying^® Fruit Fly Pheromone Sticky Card Trap>Kangbi^® Trap for male and female adults>Yikeman^® Fruit Fly Trap，and they exhibited stable attraction and a relatively long duration of efficacy. Further attraction tests on Sex Pheromone Sticky Card Trap showed that it could capture a large number of fruit flies， but its attraction to Z. tau was significantly higher than that to Z. scutellata. The attraction of male flies to two species was much higher than that of female flies，with Z. tau male flies capturing 4.8 times more than female flies and Z. Scutellata male flies capturing 18.0 times more than female flies. The Xinxi^® Sex Pheromone Sticky Card Trap exhibited optimal cost-effectiveness， and was recommended for fruit and vegetable flies control. Enhancing the performance of this product and concurrently increasing its attractiveness to female flies is an important research direction for sustainable fruit fly control.

Key words: Zeugodacus tau, Zeugodacus scutellatus, color-based attractant, sex attractant, food attractant

CLC Number:

Q969.456.8

JIA Xingyu, WANG Yuxi, LIU Min, SUN Tingzhe, ZHANG Jinming. Comparison of the field trapping efficacy of different trapping products on two species of fruit flies[J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 67(2): 438-443.

Figures/Tables 6

Table 1 Information on fruit fly trapping products

处理编号	产品名称	诱杀方式	生产单位
CK	黄色粘虫板	色诱	杭州欣禧农林科技有限公司
A	康碧^®实蝇双性引诱剂套装	性诱	南京新安中绿生物科技有限公司
B	猎虫^®实蝇诱捕器	食诱	昆明猎虫农业科技有限公司
C	依科曼^®实蝇诱捕器	性诱	北京依科曼生物技术股份有限公司
L	猎蝇^®实蝇信息素粘板	性诱	昆虫猎虫农业科技有限公司
H	强力诱虫板	性诱	杭州欣禧农林科技有限公司

Fig.1 Trapping efficacies of different fruit fly trapping products

Fig.2 The number of adult insects captured in each survey for each treatment

Fig.3 Comparison of the trapping efficacies of four sex attractants on adult fruit flies

Fig.4 The capture situation of adult fruit flies of Xinxi Sex Pheromone Sticky Card Trap

Fig.5 The ratio of male to female adult insects captured by traps for Zeugodacus tau （on the left） and Zeugodacus Scutellata （on the right）

References 19

[1]	汪兴鉴. 重要果蔬类有害实蝇概论（双翅目：实蝇科）［J］. 植物检疫，1995，9（1）：20-30.
	WANG X J. An overview of key pest fruit flies affecting fruits and vegetables（Diptera：Tephritidae）［J］. Plant Quarantine，1995，9（1）：20-30.
[2]	ZHOU L B， CHEN X L， DENG Y L，et al. Description of a new species and record of Bactrocera Macquart （Diptera，Tephritidae） from China［J］. Zootaxa，2013，3647：194-200.
[3]	余慧，邓裕亮，陈乃中.中国云南华实蝇亚属一新种记述（双翅目，实蝇科）［J］.动物分类学报，2012，37（4）：834-836.
	YU H， DENG Y L， CHEN N Z. A new species of the subgenus Sinodacus from Yunnan，China （Diptera，Tephritidae）［J］. Acta Zootaxonomica Sinica，2012，37（4）：834-836.
[4]	李学密. 桔小实蝇的危害及其综合防治技术［J］. 中国果业信息，2024（4）：65-67.
	LI X M. Damage caused by the oriental fruit fly （Bactrocera dorsalis） and its integrated management［J］. China Fruit News，2024（4）：65-67.
[5]	王涛，任艳玲，张润志，等. 贵州实蝇种类及多样性构成［J］. 植物保护学报，2016，43（5）：752-758.
	WANG T， REN Y L， ZHANG R Z，et al. Species diversity of fruit flies in Guizhou［J］. Journal of Plant Protection，2016，43（5）：752-758.
[6]	李月红，夏声广，王敏，等. 金华市为害果蔬实蝇类害虫调查初报［J］. 浙江柑橘，2023，40（3）：6-10.
	LI Y H， XIA S G， WANG M，et al. A preliminary survey on fruit flies （Diptera：Tephritidae） infesting fruits and vegetables in Jinhua City［J］. Zhejiang Ganju，2023，40（3）：6-10.
[7]	王艳俏，何春玲，崔灿，等. 金华市金东区桔小实蝇绿色防控示范区建设及成效［J］. 基层农技推广，2020，8（10）：91-93.
	WANG Y Q， HE C L， CUI C，et al. Establishment and effectiveness of a green control demonstration area for the oriental fruit fly （Bactrocera dorsalis） in Jindong District，Jinhua City ［J］. Primary Agricultural Technology Extension，2020，8（10）：91-93.
[8]	廖永林，张扬，李燕芳，等. 不同诱捕处理在苦瓜地上对瓜实蝇和桔小实蝇的诱捕效果研究［J］. 热带作物学报，2013，34（1）：142-145.
	LIAO Y L， ZHANG Y， LI Y F，et al. Trapping effects of different trapping methods to Bactrocera dorsalis and Bactrocera cucurbitae in bitter gourd field［J］. Chinese Journal of Tropical Crops，2013，34（1）：142-145.
[9]	王在凌，徐婧，张润志. 中国重要检疫性实蝇的全球分布和入侵情况［J］. 生物安全学报，2020，29（3）：164-169.
	WANG Z L， XU J， ZHANG R Z. Global distribution and invasion of important quarantine fruit flies of China［J］. Journal of Biosafety，2020，29（3）：164-169.
[10]	张政兵. 全面推进湖南省农作物病虫害绿色防控工作的思考［J］. 中国植保导刊，2019，39（5）：87-89.
	ZHANG Z B. Strategies for comprehensively promoting green pest management of crop diseases and pests in Hunan Province ［J］. China Plant Protection，2019，39（5）：87-89.
[11]	陈朗杰，刘昕，吴善俊，等. 桔小实蝇抗敌百虫品系的实验种群生物学比较研究［J］. 昆虫学报，2015，58（8）：864-871.
	CHEN L J， LIU X， WU S J，et al. A comparative study of the population biology of trichlorfon-resistant strains of the oriental fruit fly，Bactrocera dorsalis（Diptera：Tephritdae）［J］. Acta Entomologica Sinica，2015，58（8）：864-871.
[12]	潘志萍，陆永跃，曾玲，等. 桔小实蝇实验种群对敌百虫、高效氯氰菊酯和阿维菌素的抗性增长规律［J］. 昆虫学报，2008，51（6）：609-617.
	PAN Z P， LU Y Y， ZENG L，et al. Development of resistance to trichlorophon，alphamethrin，and abamectin in laboratory populations of the oriental fruit fly，Bactrocera dorsalis （Hendel）（Diptera：Tephritidae）［J］. Acta Entomologica Sinica，2008，51（6）：609-617.
[13]	湖南省植保植检站. 2022年水稻二化螟综合防控技术［J］. 湖南农业，2022（6）：15.
	Hunan Plant Protection and Quarantine Station. Integrated management of the striped rice stem borer （Chilo suppressalis） in 2022 ［J］. Hunan Agricuture，2022（6）：15.
[14]	周国珍，滕永梅，谢龙. 蔬菜害虫种类及其理化诱控技术［J］. 湖北植保，2019（6）：48-51.
	ZHOU G Z， TENG Y M， XIE L. Species of vegetable insect pests and their physical and chemical attractant-based control techniques［J］. Hubei Plant Protection，2019（6）：48-51.
[15]	吴玉玲，钱国华，张传根，等. 茶树虫害绿色防控技术研究［J］. 安徽农学通报，2014，20（24）：76-78.
	WU Y L， QIAN G H， ZHANG C G，et al. Research on green control technology of tea pest［J］. Anhui Agricultural Science Bulletin，2014，20（24）：76-78.
[16]	刘宝传，沈荣红，徐德坤，等. 梨小食心虫在苹果园的监测及理化诱控试验［J］. 落叶果树，2018，50（3）：20-22.
	LIU B C， SHEN R H， XU D K，et al. Field monitoring and physical and chemical control experiment of pod borer in apple orchard［J］. Deciduous Fruits，2018，50（3）：20-22.
[17]	金扬秀，张德满，谢传峰，等. 桔小实蝇绿色防控技术研究进展［J］. 植物检疫，2022，36（3）：1-6.
	JIN Y X， ZHANG D M， XIE C F，et al. Research advance on green prevention and control technology of Bactrocera dorsalis （Hendel）［J］. Plant Quarantine，2022，36（3）：1-6.
[18]	TAN K H， NISHIDA R. Methyl eugenol：its occurrence，distribution，and role in nature，especially in relation to insect behavior and pollination［J］. Journal of Insect Science，2012，12：56.
[19]	林嘉，杨德庆，郝旭兴，等. 实蝇引诱剂研究进展［J］. 环境昆虫学报，2021，43（6）：1398-1407.
	LIN J， YANG D Q， HAO X X，et al. Advance on the attractants of Tephritid fruit flies［J］. Journal of Environmental Entomology，2021，43（6）：1398-1407.