Comprehensive evaluation of ornamental effect in autumn and winter on 90 varieties of Camellia sasanqua in Hangzhou

doi:10.16178/j.issn.0528-9017.20250713

Abstract

Abstract:

This study used 90 Camellia sasanqua varieties（38 from the common Camellia sasanqua group，40 from the winter Camellia sasanqua group，and 12 from the spring Camellia sasanqua group）cultivated in the Hangzhou resource nursery as test materials. The 16 biological traits of these 90 Camellia sasanqua varieties were continuously observed. Using the analytic hierarchy process（AHP），a comprehensive evaluation model for the ornamental effects of Camellia sasanqua was established from three dimensions：resistance，ornamental traits，and plant traits，to screen out new varieties of Camellia sasanqua with superior ornamental effects in autumn and winter in Hangzhou. The evaluation results indicated that 90 Camellia sasanqua varieties were divided into 4 levels，14 varieties in level Ⅰ，42 varieties in level Ⅱ，24 varieties in level Ⅲ，and only 10 varieties in level Ⅳ.

Key words: Camellia sasanqua, analytic hierarchy process（AHP）, comprehensive evaluation, ornamental effect

CLC Number:

S685.14

QI Ming, GUO Weizhen, CHEN Jiesheng, JING Jiang, ZHANG Danfeng. Comprehensive evaluation of ornamental effect in autumn and winter on 90 varieties of Camellia sasanqua in Hangzhou[J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 67(6): 1529-1534.

Figures/Tables 5

References 11

[1]	徐碧玉. 茶梅［M］. 杭州：浙江科学技术出版社，2007.
[2]	庞旭凤. 茶花抗寒性评价与抗寒生理机制研究［D］. 武汉：华中农业大学，2015.
	PANG X F. Evaluation of cold resistance of Camellia and study on cold resistance physiological mechanism［D］. Wuhan：Huazhong Agricultural University，2015.
[3]	林田，李天菲，杨华，等. 茶梅品种资源的收集保存、鉴定评价及种质创新［J］. 植物遗传资源学报，2012，13（2）：207-211.
	LIN T， LI T F， YANG H，et al. Collection，conservation，evaluation and enhancement of Camellia sasanqua L. germplasm resources［J］. Journal of Plant Genetic Resources，2012，13（2）：207-211.
[4]	郭娟，邱帅，魏建芬，等. 四种园林植物对遮荫的生理响应及耐荫性评价［J］. 北方园艺，2020（6）：76-84.
	GUO J， QIU S， WEI J F，et al. Physiological response to shade and shade-tolerant capability of four species of ornamental plants［J］. Northern Horticulture，2020（6）：76-84.
[5]	张炳江. 层次分析法及其应用案例［M］. 北京：电子工业出版社，2014：30-46.
[6]	陈焕杰. 山茶种质资源核心库构建［D］. 杭州：浙江农林大学，2013.
	CHEN H J. Construction of core germplasm of Camellia ［D］. Hangzhou：Zhejiang A & F University，2013.
[7]	武荣花，刘引，卜燕华，等. 北京地区138个月季品种夏秋观赏效果综合评价［J］. 中国园林，2021，37（10）：118-122.
	WU R H， LIU Y， BU Y H，et al. Comprehensive evaluation of 138 rose varieties in summer and autumn in Beijing［J］. Chinese Landscape Architecture，2021，37（10）：118-122.
[8]	冯慧，赵世伟，卜燕华，等. 北京地区月季综合评价体系的建立［J］. 中国园林，2021，37（1）：116-121.
	FENG H， ZHAO S W， BU Y H，et al. Establishing of a comprehensive evaluation system for modern garden roses in Beijing［J］. Chinese Landscape Architecture，2021，37（1）：116-121.
[9]	陈艺荃，潘宏，魏云华. 山茶花品种观赏性状的主成分分析与观赏价值综合评价［J］. 福建农业学报，2019，34（5）：551-559.
	CHEN Y Q， PAN H， WEI Y H. Principal component analysis and comprehensive evaluation on ornamental value of varieties of Camellia ［J］. Fujian Journal of Agricultural Sciences，2019，34（5）：551-559.
[10]	韦娇媚，张春雅，余乃明，等. 基于层次分析法的茶花品种的综合评价方法：CN201510489013.4［P］. 2015-11-18.
[11]	张斌，刘信凯，尹丽娟. 6个多季茶花新品种在上海的观赏性及适应性评价［J］. 园林，2021，38（12）：100-105.
	ZHANG B， LIU X K， YIN L J. Evaluation on the ornamental characteristics and adaptability of six multi-season Camellia in Shanghai［J］. Landscape Architecture，2021，38（12）：100-105.

约束层	约束层权重	指标层	指标层权重	综合权重
C1	0.539	P1	0.539	0.291
		P2	0.297	0.161
		P3	0.164	0.088
C2	0.297	P4	0.324	0.096
		P5	0.227	0.067
		P6	0.153	0.045
		P7	0.101	0.030
		P8	0.079	0.024
		P9	0.039	0.012
		P10	0.039	0.012
		P11	0.038	0.011
C3	0.164	P12	0.418	0.069
		P13	0.264	0.043
		P14	0.160	0.026
		P15	0.097	0.016
		P16	0.061	0.010

约束层	约束层权重	指标层	指标层权重	综合权重
C1	0.539	P1	0.539	0.291
		P2	0.297	0.161
		P3	0.164	0.088
C2	0.297	P4	0.324	0.096
		P5	0.227	0.067
		P6	0.153	0.045
		P7	0.101	0.030
		P8	0.079	0.024
		P9	0.039	0.012
		P10	0.039	0.012
		P11	0.038	0.011
C3	0.164	P12	0.418	0.069
		P13	0.264	0.043
		P14	0.160	0.026
		P15	0.097	0.016
		P16	0.061	0.010

[1]	QUAN Xinhua, WANG Ruisen, SHEN Meng, YUAN Ye, YAO Xiangtan. Comprehensive evaluation of agronomic traits and nutritional quality in 15 non-heading Chinese cabbage varieties [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 67(5): 1180-1186.
[2]	GONG Fuyu, XU Jianzhong, LI Zhenfeng, WANG Zhi’an. Comprehensive evaluation of germplasm resources of Ophiopogon japonicus from Zhejiang Province based on principal component and cluster analysis [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 67(3): 644-651.
[3]	CHEN Yushan, LOU Kexun, MIAO Qiang, LOU Jun, MA Guanxi, CAI Xiaojun. Comprehensive evaluation of 16 miniature Phalaenopsis varieties based on phenotypic characters [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 67(3): 698-703.
[4]	HUANG Shuyong, ZAN Jingyi, WANG Hui, WANG Xiaodong, WANG Xiaoguo. Relationship between composition of soil particle size and quality of flue⁃cured tobacco in western Henan [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2026, 67(2): 369-375.
[5]	WANG Qinghua, YUE Lixin, LIU Zezhou, GAO Limin. Effects of NaCl stress on the germination of different types of welsh onions [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 66(9): 2157-2164.
[6]	WANG Ruisen, QUAN Xinhua, YANG Hailong, JIANG Cong, YAO Xiangtan, ZHANG Quanfeng. Comprehensive evaluation of phenotypic traits in late direct-seeded rapeseed in Northern Zhejiang [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 66(5): 1173-1180.
[7]	TANG Xiaowei, ZHANG Ningning, LIU Chen, HENG Yan, QU Xiaohui, SHAO Heping. Different water and fertilizer treatments on the ornamental traits and root activity of Phalaenopsis aphrodite [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 66(4): 973-978.
[8]	WANG Mengru, CAI Run, DONG Guoxin, SHI Qinghua, ZHANG Yan. Evaluation of yield and agronomic traits of taste tomato varieties [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 66(12): 2994-3001.
[9]	ZHANG Xiaojuan, XU Qiubin, ZHANG Min. Comprehensive evaluation of the landscape application value of hardy waterlily varieties in Hangzhou area [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 66(10): 2412-2417.
[10]	WANG Meiqing, XU Ping. Comprehensive evaluation of agricultural natural resources in Zhejiang Province [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2025, 66(1): 211-217.
[11]	XU Zhihao, FU Manman, DING Xiaoyu, WU Chao, GUO Fangqi. Selection of low-temperature-tolerant varieties of spray cut chrysanthemum and differences in the growth of tissue culture seedlings [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 65(8): 1843-1850.
[12]	CAI Yi, YANG Jian, YANG Yang, CHENG Zhimin, XIE Bing, TANG Ming, YANG Yide, YAN Min. Comprehensive evaluation of new flue-cured tobacco varieties in Yibin [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 65(6): 1346-1350.
[13]	ZHANG Xiaoqing, ZHANG Yarong, DONG Wenli, LI Xiaoting, ZHANG Wenbiao, SUO Mingchun, WANG Zhenyu, LIU Yaling. Comprehensive evaluation of 15 alfalfa varieties in Inner Mongolia central region [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 65(4): 971-978.
[14]	ZHANG Jianying, ZHU Guofu. Grey comprehensive evaluation and screening of new hybrid late japonica rice varieties [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 65(3): 525-530.
[15]	HUANG Ting, ZUO Zhong, FAN Jinxin. Comprehensive evaluation of 7 salt tolerant greening tree species based on grey correlation analysis method [J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2024, 65(10): 2443-2446.